Losing Our Measles-free Status

Analyzing what happened changed my view of who and what is to blame

Last week, the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) officially revoked the measles elimination status the US achieved in 2000. Elimination was achieved after decades of vaccine development, tireless public health advocacy and work, and years of expanding herd immunity thanks to vaccination requirements.

This loss touches on what has happened to the scientific record and its interface with the public, since the inciting event happened in a prominent medical journal and a libertarian tech and epistemic culture embraced by scientific publishers since then has promulgated and sustained it.

The 2000 measles elimination status was granted two years after the Andrew Wakefield MMR-autism fraud paper appeared in the Lancet. That paper has been a whipping post for years as a sign that yes indeed the peer review process can be flawed and therefore needs to be completely upended, disrupted, and reconstituted using new ways of thinking based on technological models like Github and open source practices. No option has proven superior, but that hasn’t stopped fanciful analogies to tech-adjacent approaches from diverting us from serious solutions.

Having gradually explored the Wakefield paper’s role in all of this while watching related events unfold before, across, and after an actual pandemic, I’ve become more forgiving of the Lancet’s part of the story. To me, the blame for what has transpired in the US and elsewhere when it comes to vaccine skepticism and anti-vax attitudes rests more squarely on the shoulders of the following culprits, who have all played roles in COVID-19 anti-vax theories as well:

  1. Wakefield himself
  2. Search engines
  3. Social media
  4. The attention economy
  5. The open science movement
  6. Grifters exploiting it all

The Lancet published the Wakefield paper in a section known among its readers for more speculative and potentially questionable papers. A lot of journals have room for papers like this either intrinsic in the rubric system, accomplished through correspondence, or a combination of the two. Editors don’t want to miss out on something that might prove to be important, so having a section for more speculative works relieves this burden. Sometimes, it pays off, giving a top journal a relationship with researchers who turn out to have found something really exciting and important while keeping it in a zone experts know is even more preliminary than the rest of the journal’s contents.

Wakefield fooled the editors of the Lancet by lying about the patients he recruited and what he found. This cannot be over-emphasized. He lied, and he lied because he hoped his lies would pave his way to riches.

If he hadn’t lied, none of this would have happened.

The rumor mill suggests the editorial team at the Lancet was uneasy about the paper, but placing it in the “well, maybe not” editorial section seemed a safe-enough choice. After all, their readers understood the signal the editors were sending, and despite all the wording about the permanence of print, weekly printed journals were usually quickly forgotten, buried in stacks or thrown away.

But the world was about to change.

Wakefield turned out to be a liar par excellence, convincing his employer to aid and abet him by pumping up the paper with PR, making phone banks available to him to field calls, and so forth. They engaged in a creepy PR campaign at his urging, yet we often forget about that.

Because what happened next made even that seem superfluous.

The fake paper and creepy PR got covered by a few big newspapers and downstream wire services. Most likely, all of this would have come to nothing more than a tempest in a teapot — a few weeks of hype and needless doubts that would have faded in the face of the next big stories and a full-court press from medical authorities, mainly pediatricians. But one major new entrant was about to change the world — Google.

Wakefield’s 1998 paper came out right about the time Google was launching. Online search engines have a couple of functions, and a key function is storage. If information isn’t stored in their databases, it can’t be queried. Google got the Lancet article’s information and the press coverage, and stored it in databases suddenly available worldwide. The fraudulent paper and its initial amplification in the press became more available and persistent than anyone could have guessed.

  • Feel like you’re stuck with the same franchises, bands, TV reboots, and so forth? Blame the networking of hard drives and incentives to drive clicks.
    • New stuff is always fighting a major uphill battle online now.

Before long, Google launched AdWords, giving them a business incentive to elevate things that got a lot of clicks. Anti-vax fears got a lot of clicks. Soon, quaint search engines like AltaVista and Ask Jeeves went up in smoke, and Google owned 95%+ of the search market.

I worked at the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) in 1998, when the Wakefield paper came out and Google launched. The mixture seemed benign at the time, but soon some problems became apparent. Information from the CDC and AAP about MMR vaccines and the safety of the mercury-based preservative (thimerasol) was relegated to Page 2 of Google search results, making them effectively disappear for 99% of searchers. The Wakefield fraud got more clicks, so it dominated Page 1 of Google, and became entrenched.

The effects of storing, collating, and persistently presenting high-click misinformation to make money in the attention economy became clear in 2007, when Jenny McCarthy found the Wakefield fraud after her son’s autism diagnosis. She went onto Oprah to alert everyone to what she’d found, and soon Google’s search results were cemented around McCarthy, Wakefield, and vaccine-autism connections.

In 2007, Facebook launched, its algorithms built to further exploit the attention economy by keeping hot topics front and center. Anti-vaccine messages were already in high circulation thanks to Google, so they provided just the kind of enragement/engagement bait Facebook was made to profit from. When COVID-19 arrived, the social media clickbait engines kicked into high gear, further aided and abetted by another attention economy entrant, Substack.

Another thing happened in 2007 — the real grifters appeared, with Eric Gladen launching the World Mercury Project, inspired by the idea that a preservative in MMR vaccines (thimerasol) was causing the autism. This organization would leverage social media and soon attract Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., as a board member. He would become chair of the board in 2015, urge it to be renamed Children’s Health Defense, and would go on to become the Secretary of HHS whose policies, messaging, and practices caused the US to finally — 26 years later — lose its measles elimination status.

Another culprit has been the open science movement, which has embraced cyber-libertarianism to such a degree that even mentioning the possibility of public health mandates (handwashing, vaccines, seatbelts) can get a person ostracized, fired, or bullied. Such cyberlibertarians have been central to the commercial and ideological success of the MAHA movement while allowing preprints linking vaccines to all sorts of nonsense to be posted, promulgated, and promoted. Jay Bhattacharya and others rose on these, and the head of medRxiv has been a major participant in what seems likely to be RFK, Jr.’s next act — suing for vaccine injury claims. Yet, the founders of the oligarch-funded cyberlibertarian biomedical preprint servers associated with openRxiv continue to crow about their heritage, even as it becomes clearer the billionaires playing science are just the richest of the grifters and that their grifts around “open” have been a stain on science and society instead of the triumph they like to believe.

This certainly isn’t the entire story, but it’s more than most people know.

  • The intrinsic aspects — vaccines given to children, the invisible nature of their effects, and so forth — are also key. It’s why these grifters also pick on fluoridation. Invisible, population-based, and familiar preventative treatments are perfect for conspiracy theorists.
    • Drug scandals in cardiology or oncology don’t carry the same vibes or doubts of the invisible.
      • The anti-vax people also don’t like to think that an entire population might be biologically similar enough to be addressed by a common intervention because they are racist eugenicists, but that’s another story.

All of this gets to how badly our digital information systems are serving us. They have given misinformation a business model. As a result, an entire generation has grown up thinking vaccines are risky and potentially unnecessary. As epidemiologist and incoming Senator Abdul El-Sayed told STAT News this weekend, “We’ve created the space for a few grifters to come in and in effect lie to the public, to create a level of distrust in science and in public health that has had disastrous consequences.”

Who has? We have.

Grifter messaging has been widely distributed and persistently platformed by digital media incentivized by the attention economy. People have gained wealth, power, and influence through the lies spread by digital media. We have done little to nothing to stop them, and all too often have aided and abetted them.

Kids and adults have died as a result. The US has lost its measles elimination status, something I remember celebrating when it was achieved in 2000.

Don’t put all or even most of the blame at the Lancet’s feet. Blame Wakefield, Google, Meta, our embrace of cyberlibertarian and “open” science practices, and grifters of all kinds.

Wakefield struck steel to flint, the Lancet trusted him, and the rest took a spark that would have normally fizzled out in print media and fanned it into a massively profitable, deadly online conflagration.


Subscribe to The Geyser

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe