Podcast: Leave arXiv Alone
Those exploiting our infrastructure can return to minding their own business
arXiv was the first major preprint server, a practical Internet solution for a community seeking to exchange findings in areas like high-energy physics, particle physics, and astrophysics, all of which were growing at a rapid rate at the time due to machine-readable outputs and new sensor abilities.
First housed at Los Alamos, it moved to Cornell for a time before spinning out as an independent non-profit earlier this year. It has always been a bit of a financial albatross, so going it alone may mean more financial austerity is in the cards.
But now that it’s taken its future into its own hands and making changes, maybe it’s time to leave arXiv alone?
For its rather arcane origins and purposes, it has punched above its weight in how it has influenced thinking and been used as an example, inspiring utopian visions around the unfettered sharing of scientific findings that have proven misleading in the end.
Suffice to say, platforming preprints didn’t scale as an idea. Commercial forces of various kinds have done their best to abuse, corrupt, and extract value from them, and they have led to a litany of problems as readers here know.
But arXiv retains a talismanic power in some minds, so when extra review steps, limits on article types, and caps on article submissions were proposed, a clamor of alarm and disdain predictably followed — from the kinds of tourists and peanut gallery postulators who have taken roost in the open science era.
So today we’ll discuss a basic question about freedom, community boundaries, and grace:
- Can’t we just leave arXiv alone now?
We discuss why treating care and trust as antediluvian is ridiculous, why others keep wanting to exploit our infrastructure, why gatekeeping has become a more blunt, quantitative instrument, and how techno-fascism is monoculture-adjacent and why this matters.
We also share our Discoveries of the Week.
Subscribe to our podcast
- Subscribe on Apple Podcasts
- Subscribe on Spotify
- Subscribe on Amazon Music/Audible
- Subscribe on YouTube
Music provided by Provoke the Truth — https://provokethetruth.net/
